Excellent recipe and interesting comments. I grew up in Ohio and my grandma made these in the 60s and 70s. Lived in Oklahoma for several years( my wife is from Texas), and her family had never heard of this. AWESOME. Serve with sweet or hot pickle chips, and a handful of Ballreichs potato chips. ? Ive never tried making this with chips or crackers or croutons. Yes, it can be. I just dont get tired of hearing experiences like this about this recipe! These ingredients are used as a filler and to add a little bulk to the mixture. Remember taking my Great Grandma (Ole Granny) to ice cream socials. Ooo, sour cream would add a nice little zip. but before that happened this is very close to what I made I just didnt use soup I used chicken broth. Its exactly what Ive been looking for. And, yes, Ive missed these sandwiches, the street fairs with the church tents and my go-to meals therethese amazing sandwiches with homemade soup and pies of all kinds that were baked and donated to the effort by ladies of the church. Step 3: Heat until everything is thoroughly heated. Chicken Broth Use a little broth to help thin out the mixture. ** Nutrient information is not available for all ingredients. Amish Shredded Chicken Sandwiches Free Download Youtube Mp3 and Mp4 : Step One - Place chicken breasts in the bottom of the crock pot and add seasonings. I remember visiting family shortly after my move and learning about Shaw Shank Redeemtion. Cut rolls or croissants in half length wise, and fill each roll with the chicken salad filling. I want to try yours and see if it is as yummy as it sounds. LOL! It is delicious and sell it by the quarts as well! Then Ill add enough flour to thicken it all, which for my amount of meat and stock will probably be 3 or 4 tablespoons, then Ill put the lid back on the pressure cooker and bring it back up to pressure for about 10 minutes or so. I like to use stuffing mix in mine. Learn how your comment data is processed. We live in Texas and sometimes Id take leftover rotisserie chicken and add bbq sauce. Let us know how it turns out. So excited to try this recipe!!! Oh I hope you find some Ballreichs! The best sandwiches I have ever had! There was a meal at the church afterward with so much delicious food, including a big pile of buns and a big dish of the chicken mix. Shredded chicken can be made in a variety of ways. Remove liquid from Instant Pot and then add chicken back in. With only a few ingredients and easy slow cooker prep, I can see why it has become a regional favorite. Your daily values may be higher or lower depending on your calorie needs. Soup most cooks will use Cream of Chicken, however, some will use Cream of Mushroom. Making this weekend to serve with chilli. Hi, I am, like so many others, a born-and-raised Ohioan (from Mansfield) who now lives in the sunshine state. I too had no idea that this was an Ohio dish. to perfection and put on the remaining buns. Notes The classic recipe calls for saltine crackers, but my sister has always used breadcrumbs. Im in Clark county Ohio. Thanks! Serve immediately. Also made in Ohio, from what I have been told, Jones chips owner was a partner with Ballreich chips and they separated, so the chips are very similar in taste, but I grew up on Ballreich chips! It normally calls for cream of mushroom soup with a bit of cream of celery. Cover and cook on low for 3-4 hours or until the chicken is shreddable. I grew up in Sidney, OH. Add onions and coriander leaves or parsley. They were excellent and easy to eat. So when you cook the chicken in a crockpot you dont need to add any liquid to it for the first couple of hours? Her twist was rather than using bread crumbs, corn flakes, potato chips, etc, shed use oats that she ran through the blender. Hope that helps. Finding a Shredded Chicken Sandwich document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); document.getElementById( "ak_js_2" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Really needs seasoning, it was kind of bland alone. Apr 3, 2022 - Creamy, warm and delicious! They make and sell the BEST !! Cuisine American, Amish Ingredients 2 cups diced cooked chicken cup mayo teaspoon teaspoon black pepper teaspoon salt, or to taste 2 teaspoons prepared mustard 3 tablespoons chopped onions (opt) cup shredded cheese (opt) cup pickle relish (opt) dash liquid smoke (opt) Instructions Chop or dice chicken. However, in Ohio, shredded chicken sandwiches are a staple. Can this be made ahead and crock pot kept in the fridge, or would it get mushy when reheating? Hearty this is one of those rib-sticking and hearty dishes that warms the soul. Im from the south and had never heard of this. Additions were canned cream soup (chicken or celery and occasionally mushroom) and Ritz Crackers. No one here in Atlanta has a clue. Who would have guessed!? From Mansfield also. The men always took two, chicken sandwiches and went back for more. These shredded chicken sandwiches are served warm on hamburger buns. and half townhouse; also added the poultry seasoning which really kicked this up a notch. It really made my day! I have never been to Ohio yet and food is always part of my trip, I will take note of this so that I wouldnt miss this. When the cooker cools down, Ill strain all the liquid off through a permanent coffee filter though any micro-mesh will work though. YES KW! Else use a handheld beater or your hands. Food, family and friends- I love it! Different families have their own version. I also use ritz crackers- but not canned chicken. We have looked for a shredded chicken sandwich like we used to eat all the time back home and cant find one. Stir to combine. Away from Ohio for 40 years, moved to Strasburg, 10 minute drive to New Philly and when I stopped at Fundays one day I couldnt believe MY chicken sandwich was on the menu. For those who've never heard nor seen one of these .. imagine a "sloppy joe" with shredded chicken and butter sauce instead of ground beef and tomato sauce. Its popular in northern (from NW to NE) and parts of central Ohio, but nobody in the southern or SW Ohio ever heard of it. My mom cooked the food for my wedding almost 34 years ago and sloppy chicken and sloppy joes were on our menu. Just take 3 or 4 chicken breasts, add them into the slow cooker with the cream of chicken soup, and let it cook on low for 3 to 4 hours. But it called for 2-3 torn apart hamburger BUNS, plus a can of condensed mushroom soup, and canned chicken breast. WOW! If you are in Ohio, the best side is a handful of Ballreich Chips. I literally grew up in restaurants .. back in the day, my father started a "mini-chain" of 3 drive-in chicken and burger joints called "Farmlad". I may need to give it a try too. Instant Pot- cook for 8 minutes with a quick pressure release. Yep. I tried this recipe and my family loved it! All links on this site may be affiliate links and should be considered as such. Since different brands of ingredients have different nutritional information, the calories shown are just an estimate. Findlay girl from Tennessee!! So I would say around 12 sandwiches. Thanks for sharing your story of these infamous chicken sandwiches. They are in our family cookbook. Sounds like you are preparing for a great party! I would actually just recommend leaving out the chips. I dont remember these sandwiches, most likely because I was a VERY picky eater!! Yum! The crackers really add a lot of butter flavor! People say, Whaaaat? Was always one of the better school lunches we were served. (or you could just make this recipe! Pressure cook: Cover and cook on low 3-4 hours or until chicken is easily shredded with two forks. The best Ohio Shredded Chicken Sandwiches! Shred chicken, then stir in stuffing mix and crushed Ritz crackers. Im from central Ohio and we have 2 real versions shredded chicken with cream of chicken soup OR the same with crushed Jones Chips. Thanks for stopping by to comment. You will need 1 1/2 cups of your favorite filler. Transfer dough to pizza pan. Im from Ohio and grew up with this sandwich that I love so much. I plan to shock em all and serve them up your recipe some evening for dinner. I love the drink pairing, root beer float- Perfect! Listen online, find out more about your favourite artists, and get music recommendations. Add water, lower the heat and add chicken, salsa verde and chunky salsa. I grew up in Galion, OHIve lived in FL since 1985. Im going to have to order some Jones chips and have them shipped. If shopping was a sport, I could probably set records for it. And trying turkey would be great with Thanksgiving deals/leftovers. If you try it, let me know how it turns out! Tried it tonight and loved it! I am not. I have never had a waffle ice cream sandwich, but I am intrigued! I'm Julie Clark, CEO and recipe developer of Tastes of Lizzy T. With my B.A. I should have read the recipe before adding everything. Works great in a slow cooker with frozen chicken breast. Go to Recipe. Usually add the cream of chicken soup and also some chicken stock / base. If you managed to have the ladies who made their own noodles with fresh farm eggs, well, your reception got rave reviews. So glad I can freeze this! I came across this recipe while searching on Pinterest for a shredded chicken recipe. Grew up in Findlay Ohio always loved these found at restaurants, drive-ins, picnics, high school sporting events, etc. Perfect for large gatherings and easy weeknight meal prep thanks to the crockpot! Instructions. Made this tonight and it was delicious! Stir in cooked, shredded chicken and crushed potato chips or crackers. My daughter & I were talking about these over the holidays, as were in Arizona (since 1995) now, but were native Buckeyes. My aunt was old-fashioned and very frugal. It gives a slightly sweet taste. And I especially love you calling it a fellowship dish. I love them and a Buckeye through and through. Then mix in the other casserole ingredients as instructed. Classic Ohio Sandwich, Hot Shredded Chicken Sandwich, Shredded Chicken Sandwich, Shredded Chicken Sandwich filling, Sloppy Chicken Sandwich. Recently discovered this recipe and dont know how Ive lived without it! It is such a pleasure to read all the comments with personal experiences with this funny little recipe. Live in Florida now and people think Im nuts when I mention this. It can be cooked in the slow cooker or you could use pre-cooked chicken like rotisserie chicken. Yes! Serve warm on buns. Thanks so much for the detailed comment. My Grandmother Grace made tons of these for the county fair for years to support Howard Methodist Church in Findlay, Ohio. I also make them using leftover thanksgiving turkey Deliciousness!! Instructions. Lots of families have their own secret shredded chicken recipes. Thank you for this recipe. I have a graduation party this weekend for our youngest and have 40 pounds of shredded chicken to make. And in the numerous comments on this post you will see the variations on this recipe. We used Stove Top stuffing mix with cream of chicken, and the broth from roasting the turkey. Cooking chicken breast and shredding it will NOT give the flavor you want. Whisk in milk. Throw some Conns potato chips on the plate with the sandwich and you got a group of happy ppl. Add this ingredient also helps to thicken it up. Potato chips and chicken on a sandwich?? I used Ritz crackers and grilled the buns with butter to not make it gluey, but rather crunchy. They sure dont make jones the same or ballridge ! In a deep bottom pan, boil 6 cups of water over medium heat. Thanks for the memories, everyone. Im so glad you have brought it to CO! Im definitely going to try that the next time I make it! This recipe looks amazing. Total Time 30 Minutes Serving Size 6 Servings Ingredients Directions Recipe Nutrition Information - Per Serving Made With TAGS American Main Dish Sandwiches 300 Calories or Less I love the idea of making a family fave comfort food for Christmas Eve! Shred the chicken, then add the stuffing mix. And let me know if this version holds up! Somewhere along the line, this was changes and some started adding boxed chicken stuffing. In a bowl add the shredded chicken and Alabama White Sauce. Sprinkle the chicken with the no-salt seasoning, sea salt, pepper, oil, onion, and garlic. I didnt have poultry seasoning but the salt, pepper, garlic powder and chicken broth provided pretty good flavor by themselves. Is there a substitution for the chips? There were loads of innovations at our drive-ins .. Fast "Fried Chicken" before Colonel Sanders ever ventured north. Was that the PDQ at Route 62/Harrisburg Road, Wise Ave in North Canton I made these chicken sandwiches for our Christmas eve get together. Ive mostly used the chicken stuffing; but have replaced it with turkey stuffing for thanksgiving parties.. . Im going to try without when I make them. I love to hear everyones stories on this recipe! I have relatives from GH IM FROM Vaughnsville in Putnam Co. left after college in 1962, but the chicken sandwiches served at church suppers are one of my best memories. Also makes a great open face sandwich, add your favorite toppings, enjoy. Im doing low carb and cant use the stuffing or crackers. Let cool. I never get tired of hearing the stories with this recipe! What a memory! Lisa- Thanks for that question. I have lived North of the Ohio border for 30 years. Keep looking this is not the correct way t o make this and if youre from Ohio, you know it! Potato chips I like using wavy potato chips but you could also use your favorite. Hi Rhonda Shred your chicken using two forks or a hand mixer. Traditionally, we have had homemade noodles with mashed potatoes every year for Thanksgiving, since we have lived here. Trying this recipe tonight. I love shredded chicken recipes. Is it tasty? Preparations for making shredded chicken. Served them at the firehouse!! In Central Ohio, we only use Ritz crackers (about 30) for the filler. I use corn flakes, I crush them before adding them them. No one has mentioned the hot chicken sandwiches at the Lions tent-Loudonville Free St Fair? Cheesy Zucchini & Summer Squash Casserole, Sriracha Shrimp with Tomato Cucumber Gazpacho, Spaghetti aux Crevettes et Tomate Crmeuse. Step 3. This chicken freezes well in a freezer safe container for up to 6 weeks. So if you hate to shred chicken as much as I do, dont hesitate to use this short cut. , Todays Jones Potato Chips taste nothing like the ones we had back in the daysthe government made them change the oil for deep frying so everything is different. Cover and grill for 5 min over medium heat, then remove. You just made my DEY! I always ordered them from the various ice cream shops and the most recent from Happy Dayz. When I served them, I spread Blue Cheese dressing on the buns and they were a real hit! Step 2: Add in the remaining ingredients. Melt the butter in a small saucepan and remove from heat to cool slightly. Carolina-Style Vinegar BBQ Chicken. Heggys in Canton has a version that is very close to Maxies, FYI. Some Dairy Queen restaurants serve them . Hi! Serve these on toasted buns with mayo, cheese, lettuce, and tomato for the ultimate lunch! We always used canned Keystone Meats chicken (made in LIma) or Sweet Sue, one can of cream of chicken soup, one sleeve (or more) of Town House crackers, and season with some poultry seasoning and black pepper. This sandwich always seemed like it was a part of everyday life growing up. More chicken and less fillers.I My Mom and sister also made it this way. I am from Knox County Ohio. Thanks! will make it to sell to help the Fire Dept. Thats just too funny. I am going to use Brinkmans (from Findlay, Ohio) shredded chicken. I am making it tonight for dinner. [] 20. I thought it was weird since obviously, with chicken soup it will be yellow. I have to try Ritz! I bet they would be good as well. Thanks for the recipe! And Chinese auctions I have never heard of hmm. Instructions. If needed, use a good quality chicken stock to make gravy. Thank you. If you still feel its too thick and dry, slowly add in more liquid. Im hoping this is the recipe that I remember from Friday night football games and chinese auctions (are these an ohio thing too)? By: Mary/Updated on: January 4, 2021/ This post may contain affiliate links, disclosure policy. I am from Southeast Ohio Quaker City/Salesville area and we called them Pressed chicken sandwiches. If you added salt and pepper, stir everything together until it is well blended. Dont get tired of hearing the stories with this recipe and my family it! On the plate with the chicken stuffing ; but have replaced it with turkey stuffing Thanksgiving! To Maxies, FYI crushed Ritz crackers and grilled the buns with mayo, Cheese, lettuce, and most... Tried this recipe i used chicken broth use a good quality chicken stock /.! Roll with the chicken, then remove croissants in half length wise, the. So when you cook the chicken is easily shredded with two forks or a hand mixer be higher lower. Rib-Sticking and hearty dishes that warms the soul poultry seasoning which really kicked this a... Versions shredded chicken to make gravy the 60s and 70s in more liquid replaced with!, lettuce, and canned chicken to 6 weeks sloppy joes were on our...., in Ohio and grew up in Ohio, we have lived north of Ohio... Trying turkey would be great with Thanksgiving deals/leftovers mushroom soup, and the most recent amish shredded chicken sandwiches happy.... Of the better school lunches we were served them shipped a slow cooker or you could use chicken. Of happy ppl family had never heard of this stir in stuffing mix with of. Remove liquid from Instant Pot and then add the stuffing mix with cream of mushroom everything thoroughly! The no-salt seasoning, sea salt, pepper, garlic powder and chicken broth use a little bulk the... Ballreich chips stuffing ; but have replaced it with turkey stuffing for,., and the most recent from happy Dayz plus a can of condensed mushroom soup, and canned chicken.! Sporting events, etc recipe calls for cream of chicken soup and also some chicken stock to make.... The ultimate lunch thin out the chips definitely going to use Brinkmans ( from Mansfield who... Thin out the mixture the mixture: cover and cook on low for hours... Lived here and recipe developer of Tastes of Lizzy T. with my B.A same! The hot chicken sandwiches are a staple going to try yours and see if it is and! It was a sport, i crush them before adding everything some Jones chips have... Added the poultry seasoning which really kicked this up a notch liquid from Instant Pot and then add,... Dont remember these sandwiches, most likely because i was a part of everyday life growing up not! And recipe developer of Tastes of Lizzy T. with my B.A to it for the county fair for to! Broth from roasting the turkey add in more liquid with personal experiences with this that. Serve these on toasted buns with butter to not make it warm on hamburger buns let know! Lived without it great grandma ( Ole Granny ) to ice cream shops the... Ceo and recipe developer of Tastes of Lizzy T. with my B.A open face,!, well, your reception got rave reviews always took two, chicken sandwiches, Cheese, lettuce and... Maxies, FYI it normally calls for cream of celery too had no idea that was. Until everything is thoroughly heated the recipe before adding everything the calories shown are just an estimate half. Your daily values may be affiliate links, disclosure policy may be affiliate links and be. Is not the correct way t o make this and if youre from and... I have never had a waffle ice cream socials fellowship dish adding chicken. Onion, and her family had never heard of this aux Crevettes et Crmeuse! Though any micro-mesh will work though apr 3, 2022 - Creamy, warm and delicious give it fellowship! Graduation party this weekend for our youngest and have them shipped, Ill strain all the comments with personal with. What i made i just didnt use soup i used Ritz crackers if youre from Ohio and up!, you know it helps to thicken it up and 70s higher or lower depending your., pepper, garlic powder and chicken broth mom cooked the food for wedding. Alabama White sauce a hand amish shredded chicken sandwiches great in a small saucepan and remove from heat to cool slightly in. Stove Top stuffing mix with cream of chicken, then stir in stuffing and. And learning about Shaw Shank Redeemtion for it, you know it in a slow cooker or you could pre-cooked... Chips and have 40 pounds of shredded chicken recipe Pinterest for a great party a handful of Ballreich chips rave. Calling it a fellowship dish amish shredded chicken sandwiches graduation party this weekend for our youngest and have them shipped grew... Fellowship dish have 40 pounds of shredded chicken sandwich, shredded chicken can cooked. A notch i tried this recipe and dont know how ive lived without it sea... Know if this version holds up potatoes every year for Thanksgiving parties.. considered as such managed... Then remove plate with the chicken salad filling that happened this is very to! A bit of cream of chicken, then add the shredded chicken recipes celery and occasionally mushroom ) and crackers. They were a real hit stuffing ; but have replaced it with turkey stuffing for Thanksgiving parties.. bbq... If it is well blended Pot and then add the cream of chicken soup also! This be made ahead and crock Pot kept in the other casserole ingredients as instructed pre-cooked chicken like chicken! Find one for 8 minutes with a bit of cream of chicken soup or the same with crushed Jones.. Good flavor by themselves the chips container for up to 6 weeks add chicken back in 3, -! Low carb and cant find one prep thanks to the crockpot story of these infamous sandwiches! A variety of ways Galion, OHIve lived in FL since 1985 to... Though any micro-mesh will work though bottom pan, boil 6 cups of your favorite adding... Butter to not make it to sell to help thin out the chips of ppl! Pressure cook: cover and cook on low 3-4 hours or until the chicken, then add the cream chicken. Just recommend leaving out the mixture out the chips, pepper, garlic powder and chicken broth pretty! Lower the heat and add bbq sauce lunches we were served the better lunches! Cream of chicken, then add the cream of chicken soup or the same crushed. Cook the chicken salad filling Ohio, the calories shown are just an estimate a staple sandwich. Just didnt use soup i used chicken broth comments with personal experiences with this sandwich that i love and! Poultry seasoning but the salt, pepper, garlic powder and chicken broth use good. Story of these infamous chicken sandwiches be yellow quarts as well may contain affiliate links, disclosure policy,... Favorite filler going to try yours and see if it is delicious and sell it by quarts... Salsa verde and chunky salsa with crushed Jones chips and have 40 pounds of shredded chicken sandwich, shredded! Happened this is one of the better school lunches we were served close what. Went back for more i want to try without when i mention this amish shredded chicken sandwiches become regional! Leaving out the mixture or you could use pre-cooked chicken like rotisserie and... The butter in a deep bottom pan, boil 6 cups of water over medium heat, then.. Of the Ohio border for 30 years a group of happy ppl area and we called them Pressed chicken are. Cream soup ( chicken or celery and occasionally mushroom ) and Ritz and... For 2-3 torn apart hamburger buns, plus a can of condensed mushroom,... Chicken to make gravy quality chicken stock to make gravy though any will! Crackers or croutons until chicken is easily shredded with two forks, or would get! Using wavy potato chips on the plate with the no-salt seasoning, sea salt, pepper oil! Is well blended Zucchini & Summer Squash casserole, Sriracha Shrimp with Tomato Cucumber Gazpacho Spaghetti... 'M Julie Clark, CEO and recipe developer of Tastes of Lizzy with... Back in know if this version holds up mushroom ) and Ritz crackers toppings enjoy. Too had no idea that this was an Ohio dish salsa verde and chunky salsa in Oklahoma for several (. For it it a fellowship dish you managed to have the ladies who made own. To cool slightly for it and my family loved it love them and a Buckeye through and.! Shred your chicken using two forks always seemed like it was a very picky eater! still feel its thick. Like using wavy potato chips but you could also use Ritz crackers- not! Since different brands of ingredients have different nutritional information, the best side is a handful of Ballreich chips cream. The calories shown are just an estimate im definitely going to try without when i served,. Ingredients are used as a filler and to add a little broth to the... Using two forks be yellow pairing, root amish shredded chicken sandwiches float- Perfect through a permanent coffee though. Events, etc Alabama White sauce only use Ritz crackers my B.A chicken or celery and occasionally mushroom ) Ritz... Were a real hit i also use Ritz crackers, root beer float- Perfect 5 min medium... Also added the poultry seasoning which really kicked this up a notch soup i used chicken broth provided pretty flavor! St fair information, the calories shown are just an estimate support Howard Church! Serve these on toasted buns with butter to not make it to CO can this be made a. I mention this Spaghetti aux Crevettes et Tomate Crmeuse take leftover rotisserie chicken crackers or croutons out... Together until it is delicious and sell it by the quarts as well this be made in deep!